148 | Central and West Asia and North Africa (CWANA) Report

domestic markets. Coherent policies require an integration of AKST and agricultural production in national development strategies and plans to reconcile conflicting views and ambitions with regard to national goals such as national security, food sovereignty (virtual water trade, etc.), economic growth and development, and quality of life. To strengthen the position of CWANA producers and agrofood businesses in international, globalized markets the negotiating capacity in trade talks may have to be further developed since proactive engagement in trade negotiations and active participation in international programs and initiatives will be required. Reducing the costs and delays associated with border transit procedures and intensifying current efforts to create a low-cost, green corridor that gives improved access to neighboring markets (trade agreements with regional trading partners) may represent further options for making CWANA markets more efficient. Principles of good governance such as representation, transparency, accountability and civil society participation may ensure that social and environmental concerns will be better represented in negotiation processes and resulting agreements.

5.2.4.5 Risk management and property rights

Besides risk-reducing approaches at production level, such as investments in supplemental irrigation facilities or diversification of production, policies have to provide a framework that promotes innovation by reducing associated risks. Well-functioning savings and credit schemes and the development of insurance programs for farmers will encourage farmers to make necessary investments and implement innovative technologies and approaches. Proactive risk management strategies and policies will have to replace the currently prevailing reactive disaster management. This is particularly important in view of the increasing threat of more frequent extreme events caused by climatic change such as droughts, storms and floods, and possible abrupt changes in globalized markets. Improved social safety nets and compensatory policies may also help safeguard the disadvantaged against likely negative effects of structural adjustments and reforms.

Although intellectual property rights are intended to stimulate innovation, enhancing investment in research and access to potentially useful technologies from abroad, they are based on a paradigm of market-led development that contrasts with the traditional approach in agricultural research, which focused on sharing ideas and producing public goods. Currently the issue of IPR is particularly discussed in the domain of plant breeding and biotechnology. The IPR regulatory environment needs to be reshaped to facilitate the generation, dissemination, access to and use of AKST. IPR regulations will have to balance private and communal rights while considering national interests and benefits for local communities. Benefits based on local and traditional knowledge will particularly have to be protected and shared in an equitable manner.

5.2.4.6 Institutional reform and role of government

In CWANA countries where private sector institutions are weak and reform still has far to go, the state retains

 

major responsibilities. Important domains on which government should focus its resources and activities include policy formulation, guidance on legislation and regulation, and provision of essential public services in the areas of seed and plant protection, animal health, border control, food safety, and product standards and certification. Preparing a coherent medium-term sector strategy can form the basis not only for policy formulation but also for ministry input into budget preparation, public investment planning, and specific policies and legislation relating to land use and land reform, trade, taxation, market activity and competition, rural finance, research and extension.

Production targets should be discontinued as a policy instrument and replaced with growth in value addition, household income and export revenue. The efficiency with which essential public services are provided leaves room for improvement in many CWANA countries, and comprehensive modernization of current regulatory practices (including product standards) may be required. There are great opportunities to transfer activities such as seed and livestock breeding to the private sector, and it seems advantageous to allocate more resources to providing information and support to producers and agribusinesses on land privatization and market activity.

The ability of public institutions to reorient their activities is currently constrained by limited awareness of what is appropriate in a market economy, a reluctance to change old approaches, and a limited allocation of human and financial resources for formulating policy. Weak budgetary resources and a significant need to retrain staff and boost output are further constraints.

5.3 Implications of Various Options and Possible Mitigation Measures

Although options to achieve SDGs presented in the preceding sections will contribute to reducing hunger and improving socioeconomic conditions in CWANA, certain options to increase agricultural productivity may have negative environmental effects or be associated with social or economic drawbacks.

The increasing use of pesticides and the related pollution of the ecosystems is a big concern. The trend toward genetically uniform crops increases the potential for serious disaster by eliminating the many different strains of a given crop that farmers previously used. But government policies perpetuate conventional agriculture and discourage farming practices that could make agriculture more sustainable (Chrispeels and Sadava, 2003).

Many modern agricultural practices in the CWANA region are not environmentally sustainable as they have negative aspects (e.g., habitat conversion due to agriculture, soil erosion, and pollution from chemical pesticides and fertilizers). Modern agricultural chemicals have largely contributed to increased crop production, but they also have negative side effects such as groundwater pollution, interference in terrestrial and marine biodiversity, and health hazards to producers and consumers. Therefore, other technical options such as biological control, integrated pest management, integrated crop management, good agricultural practices and organic farming provide great opportunities for making agricultural production more sustainable (Clay, 2004).