Agricultural Knowledge, Science and Technology: Investment and Economic Returns | 519

Table 8-1 4. Relative size of environmental impacts of high-external input farming systems in absence of monetized or otherwise quantified assessments

 

Individual farmer and/or household

Local community

Downstream community

Global      Data availability society       for economic quantification"

Agricultureb

Biodiversity loss, off and on-farm species and plant genetic resources

""

 

 

-----        Some

 

Erosion and soil quality

—-

-

—-

-----        Many

 

Run-off of agro-chemicals (eutrophization)

0

-

 

Many

 

Pesticides and impact on non-target species

-

Many

 

Water table loss

-

-

 

Few

 

Fossil Fuel Use: Non-renewable and climate change impact

— (financial cost)

0

0

-----        Some

 

Genetic improvement

 

0

0

++         Many

 

Carbon sequestration

0

0

0

+++++      Some

 

Land saving

+++++

++

0

++++       Many

Livestock

Biodiversity loss, off- and on-farm species and animal genetic resources

""

 

-----        Few

 

Water contamination (surface and underground) and eutrophization

 

 

 

Some

 

Fossil Fuel Use

-

0

0

Some

 

Land use and deforestation for animal nutrition

0

0

-

-----        Many

 

GHG emissions

0

0

0

-----        Some

 

Genetic improvement

++++++

0

0

++         Some

Aquaculture

Fisheries decline (due to fishmeal production and capture of wild gravid females and/or post larvae seeds)

 

 

0

Few

 

Destruction of coast forest (e.g., mangrove for shrimp production)

 

 

 

-----        Some

 

Erosion and release of CO2 into atmosphere

-----        Few

 

Fossil Fuel Use

-

0

0

Few

 

Soil and water salinization

—-

------

-----

Few

 

Runoff of agro-chemicals

0

-

Few

 

Biodiversity loss (due to diseases, hybridization and competition with wild fish)

 

 

-----        Few

Note: + = positive impact. - = negative impact. Degree of impact: + minimal; ++ moderate; +++ high; ++++ very high, and +++++ very high likelihood of some irreversibility.
aEconomic valuation refers both to monetary and other methods of valuation tools.
bAgriculture impacts include the livestock and aquaculture impact derived from the crops required for the animal and fish nutrition industry (e.g., 33% of world feedcrop land is dedicated to animal nutrition, thus, it is a livestock impact added to agriculture).
Source: Authors' elaboration.